Sun 19 Jul 2009
Half-Blood Prince Review
Posted by Morgan YorkHello! I saw the sixth Harry Potter movie on Tuesday (a store that sells Harry Potter merchandise was doing a special screening of it, so I got to see it a day early! Whoopee!). I thought it was wonderful, and I was surprised at how little there was for me to complain about, since I’m such a diehard, nitpicky Harry Potter fan. I’d say it’s one of my favorite of the Harry Potter movies so far, and David Yates, as well as everyone else involved, did an excellent job. I only had a few qualms with the movie, and I will post them after I’m finished gushing about the parts I liked.
Now, if it isn’t obvious enough already, the remainder of this post contains spoilers from the movie!
Firstly, there was a lot of romance in this book, and unlike a lot of people (for there is a fair amount of fans that dislike the sixth book for this very reason), I adored it. One gem that stood out to me was Jessie Cave, who played Ron’s fling, Lavender Brown (or, in the books, Parvati Patil’s best friend). She didn’t have a huge part, but she pulled off being an obnoxious girlfriend so well. Her performances were best in the scene on the train where she wrote R + L in a heart in the fog of the glass (so deliciously awkward for Ron and Harry), and in the scene where Ron muttered Hermione’s name in his sleep. I can’t remember exactly what Dumbledore says after she exits the scene, but it killed me. I didn’t expect much from her, but I thought she was wonderful. There are no small parts, only small actors!
The Ron/Hermione hints (anvil-sized, anyone?) were simply amazing in this movie. What I loved about it was that it was so clearly established that Harry and Hermione were best friends and nothing more. The reason I’ve always disliked the Harry/Hermione romantic pairing is because I adore their friendship so much. I love how they lean on each other like best friends should, especially in times like that when their romantic lives encounter turbulence. Yes, Ron and Hermione were very sweet, and I must say I’m insanely excited for their scenes in both parts of the seventh movie (if you’ve read Deathly Hallows, you know what I’m talking about)!
Here’s the aspect of the romance that I didn’t like: Harry and Ginny. I am a Harry/Ginny fan, but I don’t like the way it was done in the books, much less the movies. There weren’t any hints that Harry liked Ginny in any of the books up until the book where they got together, which annoyed me to an extent. Sure, Ginny’s crush on Harry was laid out in earlier books, but that’s all it seemed like: a schoolgirl crush, not to mention the fact that Harry didn’t seem attracted to her at all. It seemed like such a last-minute decision, but JK Rowling (who I will always love, no matter how unbelievable aspects of Harry/Ginny are) apparently planned it from the beginning. If I were her, I would have stuck some of it in the end of Order of the Phoenix, even if it were subtle (maybe Harry internally commenting on Ginny’s nice smile, pretty eyes, something, anything). In a similar way, it wasn’t really developed in the movies very well, either. Harry was all over Cho, and once she’s out of the picture, Ginny randomly becomes a love interest. It really saddens me, because I think as characters they are so compatible, and so much more could have been done with it. Ginny’s feisty enough not to take any of Harry’s crap when he’s angry, and he admires her spirit. They’re an adorable couple and complement each other well, but the problem was lack of development. I think the issue was that there was too much going on in Harry’s world for enough focus to be put on Harry’s love life. And hey, I suppose that makes sense.
Anyway, I kind of went off on a tangent. What I’m getting at is, the Harry/Ginny kiss was very unsatisfying. They didn’t have much chemistry at all, and it just seemed so awkward. I prefer the book version (I almost always do) and feel like the kiss was just badly done. Bonnie Wright, Dan Radcliffe, I love both of you as actors and I’ve grown up watching you, but it could have been better!
Oh my goodness, the humor! I think this was the funniest Harry Potter movie by far. When Harry was under Felix Felicis, the theater couldn’t stop laughing. He was just so bubbly and hilarious that it was hard not to giggle. One of my favorite moments during that segment was this:
Slughorn: “Harry!”
Harry: “Sir!”
On the page it doesn’t look funny, but it’s the way Jim Broadbent and Daniel Radcliffe deliver the lines. See the movie (if you haven’t already) and you’ll get what I mean. Plus, the sexual references were so fantastic and hidden in there. My favorites would have to be Cormac McLaggen attempting to seduce Hermione by licking his finger (and Hermione’s reacting look of disgust) and Ron saying to Harry, “So, did you and Ginny do it?”
Oh, speaking of the Slug Club scene where Slughorn and several other students were eating dessert, I felt a little pang of sadness when the camera upon a face of one particular actor. The boy who played Marcus Belby (the kid devouring the dessert balls), Robert Knox, never got to see his role in the Harry Potter movie on the big screen. Last year, on May 24, 2008, at the young age of eighteen (my gosh, so young), he was stabbed to death outside of a bar while trying to protect his younger brother. My heart goes out to the poor kid. He’s been dead over a year now, and hopefully wherever he is, he’s happy.
Now, on a less depressing note, I will shift the attention to Tom Felton, who portrays Draco Malfoy. Draco actually had some interesting stuff to do in this movie (what with him being recruited by Voldemort and all, he’s transitioned from schoolyard bully to assassin, and both the book and movie prove he’s not really cut out for the latter). Holy crap, the kid can really act! I found myself feeling sorry for Malfoy, especially in the bathroom scene where the kid was crying his eyes out. I love sympathetic villains, and it demonstrates that there are shades of gray: just because someone is mean-spirited doesn’t mean they’re evil. I also loved the scene where he was faced with killing a man, and he couldn’t do it. I commend Tom Felton on his performance, especially the lines, “I have to. He’ll kill me.” He sounded like a broken little child, which is exactly how Draco felt at the time. Good job, Tom.
Helena Bonham Carter had me laughing in this movie. Honestly, Bellatrix could not have been played by anyone else. Her insane tendencies and girlish cackles made the character both humorous and frightening, which is exactly what Bellatrix is meant to be.
Okay, what was up with the Burrow catching on fire for no reason? I disliked that part, mostly because of how unnecessary it was. It didn’t do anything to move the plot along, nor did it really intensify the action. It should have been cut.
I can’t believe I almost forgot Evanna Lynch! She’s a favorite of mine because of how well she plays the part of Luna. They couldn’t have picked a better Luna–it’s like they took her out of my brain, exactly as I imagined her, voice and all. She didn’t have much to do in this, but she’s always so interesting to watch.
Well, I think that sums up everything. Needless to say, I can’t wait for Deathly Hallows!
One last note: Go see Up. It’s breathtaking. Trust me, you will cry, and cry, and cry. In a good way.
~Morgan